Despite the growing recognition of the need for diversity in advertising, a recent Hispanic Sentiment Study by We Are All Human reveals a significant disconnect between brands and the Hispanic market. This disconnect indicates a broader issue in the advertising industry, which remains one of the least diverse sectors, particularly in a city as diverse as New York.
The Current Landscape
New York City's advertising industry has experienced substantial growth over the past two decades, with jobs increasing by 49.5%, significantly outpacing the city's overall private sector growth of 36.7%. The industry also boasts some of the highest wages, with median annual incomes far surpassing those in other high-growth sectors like home health care and food services.
However, the diversity within this growing industry needs to be higher. Black and Hispanic workers are underrepresented in advertising, making up only 7.7% and 14.8% of the workforce, respectively, despite constituting 20.7% and 27.6% of the city's total workforce. This disparity is stark when considering the city's demographics, where Hispanic individuals account for 29.1% of the population.
Wage Disparities
The wage disparities in the advertising industry further highlight the racial challenges. Despite the higher wages in advertising compared to other sectors, Black and Hispanic workers still earn less than their white counterparts. The median annual income for Asian workers in advertising is $94,203; for Hispanic workers, it is $75,362; and for Black workers, it is $72,064. In contrast, the median wage for white workers is significantly higher.
A Case in Point: The Hispanic Market
The advertising industry's failure to connect with the Hispanic market is a glaring example of this diversity gap. The Hispanic Sentiment Study by We Are All Human shows that less than 5% of brands successfully engage with Hispanic consumers, representing 20% of the US population. This failure is not just a missed opportunity; it highlights the broader issue of racial insensitivity and a lack of representation in creative processes.
Consequences of the Disconnect
The consequences of this disconnect are multifaceted. On one hand, brands miss out on a lucrative, influential, and rapidly growing market segment. On the other hand, the lack of representation and understanding within advertising agencies leads to campaigns that can be culturally insensitive or even offensive. An example of this was KFC's controversial advertisement in Canada, which was criticized for its racist undertones yet submitted for a prestigious industry award.
The Path Forward
The public and private sectors need to invest in creating more pathways for people of color into the advertising industry. Initiatives similar to those in the tech sector, like the NYC Tech Talent Pipeline, could be replicated to develop a diverse talent pipeline for advertising. It Might include supporting programs that provide career exploration, paid internships, and skills-based hiring practices to open up opportunities for those without traditional academic backgrounds.
Industry leaders must also commit to genuine, sustained efforts to diversify their workforce, which includes not only hiring more people of color but also ensuring they have the empowerment and career growth opportunities needed to thrive and influence creative decisions.
Conclusion
The advertising industry's racial challenges are emblematic of broader societal issues. By failing to connect with the Hispanic market and underrepresenting people of color within their ranks, brands not only miss out on significant economic opportunities but also perpetuate cultural insensitivity. Addressing these issues requires a concerted effort to build a more inclusive and equitable advertising industry that reflects the diversity of the communities it aims to engage.
Sources:
